Star Bright Community Stories

A Collaborative Resource for Non-Profit Groups, Churches, Businesses, and Individuals Who Provide a Public Benefit.

What is Biochar?

Biochar is charred organic matter used deliberately as a soil amendment, with the intent to improve soil properties. It is made by heating biomass to high temperatures (480-1800°F) in the absence of oxygen through a process called pyrolysis. Pyrolysis chemically and physically alters the composition of the biomass, producing a highly porous, stable form of carbon and organic matter that can be used as a soil amendment.

Biochar can be produced from a variety of feedstocks, including forest residues, agricultural residues, waste, and purpose-grown biomass. The source material and the pyrolysis conditions are major factors that influence the biochar’s pH, ash content, elemental composition, and stability. Therefore, both the biochar feedstock and production conditions can have important implications for how biochar amendments influence soil properties and their efficacy for different management objectives.

Quick Points

There are many books and articles about the promise of Biochar. The major claims are storing carbon in soils, soil reclamation and mining remediation, and as a soil amendment for gardening and agriculture.

A commercial biochar market is beginning to develop in the U.S., but it is confined to laboratories, experimental field sites, mine reclamation projects, and home and community gardening.

I found no large scale agricultural use or test of its commercial value.

Biochar production appears to be profitable in a few cases, but success depends on reduced transport costs for feedstocks, pricing for carbon reductions, and demand for economic uses of biochar soil amendments.

There is a history of science behind biochar, with a significant increase in the few years. Early investigations yielded conflicting results. More recent work has identified that the successful use of biochar is highly dependent on many factors. As the science developes, researchers are achieving crop production increases at 80% and above.

Books and Articles Claim the Following Benefits

Environmental Value

Carbon Sequestration: Biochar is highly resistant to decomposition, allowing it to sequester carbon in soils for hundreds to thousands of years. This helps mitigate climate change by reducing atmospheric CO2 levels.

Possible Soil Health Improvement: When added to soil, biochar can enhance soil fertility, improve water retention, and increase microbial activity, leading to healthier crops and reduced need for chemical fertilizers.

Pollution Reduction: Biochar can adsorb heavy metals and organic pollutants, making it potentially useful for soil remediation and water purification.

Possible release of harmful contaminants: During production potentially harmful chemicals may be released.

Little smoke during production: When done correctly, biochar production creates little to no smoke.

Agricultural Applications:

Soil Amendment: Farmers might be able to use biochar to improve soil structure, enhance nutrient availability, and boost crop yields. It is especially beneficial in degraded and nutrient-poor soils. However, I found no large scale agriculture implementation. The use of petroleum based fertilizers is less costly than using biochar. This is likely because the cost of dumping large amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmospher is not included in the cost of farming.

Livestock Feed Additive: Biochar might be useful as a feed additive to improve animal digestion and reduce methane emissions from livestock, contributing to reduced greenhouse gas emissions. However, I found no large scale implementation.

Impact on Soil Structure: There are potential risks that can effect soil structure affecting erosion and landslides, etc.

Current Research and Development:

Ongoing research is focused on optimizing pyrolysis processes, understanding the long-term effects of biochar on different soil types, and exploring its potential in various environmental applications.

Studies are also examining biochar’s role in carbon markets and its economic viability for farmers and industries.

Challenges and Considerations:

Economic Feasibility: The cost of biochar production and application will need to become competitive with other soil amendments for widespread adoption.

Standardization: There is a need for standardized guidelines and quality control measures to ensure consistent and effective biochar products.

Environmental Impact: While biochar offers numerous benefits, its production and application must be managed to avoid potential negative impacts, such as the release of harmful by-products during pyrolysis.

Policy and Market Development: Governments and organizations are increasingly recognizing biochar’s potential and are supporting research, development, and adoption through grants, incentives, and regulatory frameworks.

The carbon credit market is exploring ways to include biochar projects, providing financial incentives for carbon sequestration efforts.

Commercial Use

I found the following claims in various books, articles, and on websites. I did not find any commercial operation using biochar. There are two possible reasons.

I have not looked hard enough.

There are few or none. Possibly because it is not cost efficient or the benefits are over stated.

Agriculture and Horticulture:

Soil Amendment: Farmers and horticulturists use biochar to improve soil fertility, water retention, and crop yields. Companies like Cool Planet and Biochar Supreme produce and sell biochar specifically for agricultural use.

Composting: Biochar is used to enhance composting processes by improving microbial activity and reducing odors. It is marketed by companies like Black Owl Biochar.

Livestock and Animal Husbandry:

Feed Additive: Biochar is added to animal feed to improve digestion and reduce methane emissions from livestock. Companies such as EcoChar are exploring this application.

Animal Bedding: Biochar is used in animal bedding to absorb moisture and reduce odors, benefiting animal health and farm hygiene.

Water Treatment:

Filtration Systems: Biochar is employed in water filtration systems to remove contaminants and improve water quality. Its high porosity and adsorptive capacity make it effective for this purpose. Companies like Biochar Now provide biochar for water purification applications.

Stormwater Management: Biochar is used in stormwater management systems to filter pollutants from runoff, protecting water bodies from contamination.

Environmental Remediation:

Soil Remediation: Biochar is applied to contaminated soils to immobilize heavy metals and organic pollutants, aiding in the restoration of degraded lands. Projects in this field are supported by organizations like Carbon Gold.

Mine Reclamation: Biochar is used in the reclamation of mine sites to stabilize soils and promote vegetation growth.

Construction and Materials:

Building Materials: Biochar is being incorporated into building materials, such as concrete and bricks, to enhance their properties and sequester carbon. Research and development in this area are ongoing, with companies like Carbo Culture exploring commercial opportunities.

Asphalt Additive: Biochar is added to asphalt to improve its durability and reduce its carbon footprint.

Energy Production:

Co-firing in Power Plants: Biochar can be co-fired with coal in power plants to reduce emissions and improve efficiency. This application is being explored by companies like Terra Humana.

Biochar Pellets: Biochar is processed into pellets for use as a renewable fuel source in biomass boilers and stoves.

Consumer Products:

Gardening Products: Biochar is marketed to home gardeners for improving soil health and plant growth. Products are available from companies like Wakefield Biochar and Soil Reef.

Activated Carbon Products: Biochar is processed into activated carbon for use in air and water purifiers, cosmetics, and other consumer products.

Carbon Credits and Trading:

Carbon Sequestration Projects: Biochar projects are being integrated into carbon credit markets, allowing companies and individuals to offset their carbon footprint by investing in biochar production and application. Companies like Carbon Gold and Puro.earth are involved in these initiatives.

These commercial uses demonstrate the potential of biochar across different sectors, contributing to sustainability, environmental remediation, and climate change mitigation.

Home and Community Gardening

The home and community garders appear to be more active investigating the potential for Biochar than commercial farming, the science community, and the business community.

Soil Improvement:

Enhanced Soil Fertility: Biochar can improve soil structure, increase nutrient retention, and promote beneficial microbial activitylead to healthier plants and better yields.

Improved Water Retention: Biochar’s porous structure helps soils retain moisture, reducing the need for frequent watering and making gardens more resilient to drought.

Environmental Benefits:

Carbon Sequestration: By using biochar, home gardeners can contribute to carbon sequestration. Biochar locks carbon into the soil, helping to mitigate climate change by reducing atmospheric CO2 levels.

Waste Management: Biochar production allows gardeners to recycle organic waste (e.g., garden clippings, kitchen scraps) into a valuable soil amendment, reducing the amount of waste sent to landfills.

Pest and Disease Control:

Natural Pest Deterrent: Biochar can help create a healthier soil environment that reduces the prevalence of soil-borne pests and diseases, decreasing the need for chemical pesticides.

Disease Suppression: Enhanced microbial activity in biochar-amended soils can help suppress soil-borne pathogens, leading to healthier plants.

Economic Efficiency:

Cost Savings: By improving soil health, biochar can reduce the need for chemical fertilizers and amendments, saving money in the long run.

Long-lasting Effects: Biochar remains stable in the soil for many years, providing ongoing benefits without the need for frequent reapplication.

Ease of Use:

Simple Production: Home gardeners can produce biochar themselves using small-scale pyrolysis methods or buy it from garden centers. DIY biochar production can be a rewarding and educational activity.

Versatile Application: Biochar can be mixed with compost, soil, or potting mixes, making it versatile and easy to integrate into various gardening practices.

Community and Educational Value:

Learning Opportunity: Experimenting with biochar offers a chance to learn about sustainable gardening practices, soil science, and environmental stewardship.

Community Impact: Successful use of biochar in home gardens can serve as a demonstration to neighbors and community members, promoting wider adoption of sustainable practices.

Considerations for Home Gardeners:

While there are many benefits, home gardeners should also be mindful of the following:

Quality of Biochar: Ensure the biochar is free from contaminants and produced from clean, untreated biomass.

Application Rate: Start with small amounts and observe the effects, as over-application can potentially affect soil pH and plant growth.

Integration with Soil: Mix biochar well with compost or soil before application to avoid issues such as nutrient immobilization.

Reducing Wildfire Risk with Biochar

One of the greatest factors putting a community at risk for a wildfire is the accumulation of brush. Consequently many communities have passed ordinances requiring the removal of brush. Traditionally the brush is cut, collected, and transported to a disposal location. If the brush is allowed to decompose it releases carbon dioxide and methane into the atmosphere. It might be better for the environment and less costly to turn it into biochar onsite or near to where it is collected.

The Down Side of Biochar

While biochar is generally viewed positively for its potential environmental and agricultural benefits, there are some negative articles and critiques that highlight potential challenges and drawbacks. These concerns typically fall into several categories:

Environmental Concerns:

Incomplete Combustion and Emissions: The production of biochar through pyrolysis can release harmful gases and particulates if not properly managed. Some critics worry about the environmental impact of these emissions.

Land Use and Deforestation: Large-scale biochar production could lead to increased demand for biomass, potentially causing deforestation or diverting land from food production to biochar feedstock production.

Economic Viability:

High Production Costs: The cost of producing and applying biochar can be high, making it economically unviable for many farmers and industries without subsidies or incentives.

Market Uncertainty: The market for biochar and its applications is still developing, and there is uncertainty about its long-term economic sustainability and profitability.

Scientific and Practical Challenges:

Variable Quality: The properties of biochar can vary significantly depending on the feedstock and pyrolysis conditions, leading to inconsistent results in its effectiveness as a soil amendment.

Long-Term Effects: There is ongoing debate about the long-term effects of biochar on soil health and its interactions with soil microbes, nutrients, and plants. Some studies have shown mixed or negative results.

Potential Soil Contamination: Poorly produced biochar can contain harmful substances, such as heavy metals or toxic compounds, which can negatively impact soil and plant health.

Long Term

The practice of creating and adding biochar to our soil can be sustained over the long term, provided certain conditions and best practices are followed. Here’s a detailed look at how we can continue this practice effectively:

Continuous Production:

Feedstock Availability: As long as we have a steady supply of vegetation waste (e.g., garden clippings, kitchen scraps, leaves), we can continue to produce biochar. Seasonal variations in waste production can influence the amount of biochar we can produce.

Sustainable Collection: Ensure that the collection of vegetation waste is sustainable and doesn’t deplete our garden’s natural biomass or affect its health.

Soil Health Monitoring:

Regular Soil Testing: Conduct regular soil tests to monitor nutrient levels, pH (between 6 and 7), and organic matter content. This helps ensure that the addition of biochar is beneficial and not leading to nutrient imbalances or other issues.

Observation of Plant Growth: Monitor the growth and health of our plants. If we notice any adverse effects, such as stunted growth or nutrient deficiencies, we adjust the amount or frequency of biochar application.

Application Guidelines:

Initial Application Rates: When starting, a common recommendation is to apply biochar at a rate of 5-10% by volume of the soil. This translates to about 1-2 inches of biochar tilled into the top 6-8 inches of soil.

Gradual Increase: We can gradually increase the amount of biochar added each year, but it’s important to observe how our soil and plants respond. Generally, a maximum of 10-20% biochar by volume in the soil is considered safe and beneficial.

Long-Term Effects:

Stable Carbon Storage: Biochar remains stable in the soil for hundreds to thousands of years. Its benefits in terms of soil structure, water retention, and carbon sequestration are long-lasting.

Cumulative Benefits: Over time, as we continue to add biochar, the cumulative benefits will enhance soil health. However, there’s a practical upper limit to how much biochar soil can effectively incorporate.

Avoid Over-Application:

Balance with Organic Matter: Ensure that biochar is used in combination with other organic amendments like compost. This helps maintain a balanced soil ecosystem.

Potential Risks: Over-application of biochar can lead to high soil pH, nutrient lock-up, or other imbalances. It’s crucial to maintain a balanced approach and not exceed recommended application rates.

Environmental Considerations:

Sustainable Production: Ensure that our biochar production methods are environmentally friendly. Avoid using feedstock that could contain harmful chemicals or contaminants.

Local Conditions: Consider local soil and climate conditions when determining how much biochar to apply. What works well in one region may not be as effective in another.

Conclusion

Biochar holds great promise as a sustainable solution for enhancing soil health, mitigating climate change, improving agricultural productivity, and helping with wildfire control. While there are challenges to overcome, continued research, innovation, and supportive policies are driving its development and adoption.

While biochar holds significant promise, it is important to address these challenges and criticisms through rigorous scientific research, proper regulatory frameworks, and best practices in production and application. Balancing the potential benefits with the associated risks is crucial for the sustainable development and adoption of biochar technologies.